Earlier than the web actually exploded round 2000, our entry to music was restricted.
It started on the report label stage. And not using a deal, getting distribution of your music was almost unattainable. Even for those who did, your music was run via different filters: radio, music video channels, report shops and music magazines. Your complete time, you competed with all the opposite new songs on the market, together with older established favourites.
Getting the general public’s consideration was exhausting. Getting them to half with their restricted disposable revenue to purchase your music was even more durable.
However as a result of the preliminary provide was small and the winnowing course of so stringent, rewards awaited the fortunate few who got here out the opposite facet of the star-making equipment system. We lived in a monoculture, pushed largely by radio airplay. In these days, we had a common thought of what everybody else was listening to. Music followers have been related by a typical music vocabulary and a have to know that there have been others with comparable musical tastes. And since the largest songs have been so ubiquitous, we couldn’t assist however study the lyrics to even songs we hated.
To be a mainstream artist was to be BIG: Michael Jackson-Madonna-AC/DC-Eagles massive. You can cease any stranger on the road to call three songs by any of these artists and get three appropriate solutions.
At the moment, although, all of us stay in our separate, particular person and extremely private musical bubbles, and we prefer it rather a lot. It’s so empowering to have our personal little particular area of interest that’s tailor-made for us. Due to streaming, there’s no extra “mainstream” music fan. We’re all distinctive, every with an opinion on what music is “good.”
Even with somebody as massive as Taylor Swift, her songs haven’t achieved the sort of ubiquity we used to see earlier than 2000. If you wish to take a look at that, ask a random stranger to call three Tay-Tay songs. Except you select a Swiftie, that particular person will in all probability wrestle. I work within the music trade with all kinds of music 24-7-365 and I’ve hassle.
One other instance: What was the track of the summer season of 2025? What track was in everybody’s heads over June, July and August? For the primary time in years, there was no clear winner. This underscores the truth that we’ve moved past massive artists having massive hits for the plenty. At the moment’s hits are far smaller than these of the previous as a result of the identical variety of individuals can now not come to a consensus on what we must always all be listening to. That shared expertise over a track/artist is nowhere close to what it was once.
Radio, as common because it nonetheless is, is now not as dominant because it as soon as was on the subject of getting the phrase out on a track or artist. The music video channels have disappeared. When was the final time you obtain a bodily music journal? And what number of common individuals make common visits to report shops as a result of there’s that sizzling new launch everybody says they should have? As a substitute, we’ve got streaming algorithms that routinely and continuously supply an countless parade of songs that they suppose we, as a person music fan, may like. There’s no “everybody” anymore. It’s simply “me.”
The music trade is struggling to redefine “mass attraction.” And it’s extra than simply radio airplay, streaming numbers and report gross sales. In right this moment’s music enterprise, you’ll be able to have a success exterior the realm of what was once outlined as mainstream. In truth, you’ll be stunned to find out how massive an act will be serving simply their group.
Get every day Nationwide information
Get the day’s prime information, political, financial, and present affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox as soon as a day.
Take My Chemical Romance, for instance. Once they introduced their reunion tour, I used to be stunned that they’d been booked to play stadiums. Stadiums? For an emo band that had damaged up for years and whose reunion was sidelined by COVID-19? But in a single 30-day interval this previous summer season, they averaged 42,797 individuals per present, a sellout price of 100 per cent Stunned? I used to be.
Then there are the Lumineers, the Ho Hey band that turned a Household Man meme. Throughout the identical 3o-day interval, they carried out seven sold-out area reveals, averaging 18,430 tickets per gig, leading to a mean field workplace gross of almost US$2 million per present.
Listed below are another current numbers by way of Pollstar, the bible of the touring music trade. Are any of those “mainstream” artists within the outdated sense of the definition?
- ENHYPHEN: eight reveals at 98 per cent bought, common of 20,329 tickets per gig, common gross of US$2.9 million.
- Rüfüs Du Sol: 9 reveals at 96 per cent bought, common of 18,197 tickets per gig, common gross of US$1.65 million.
- Phil Wickman/Brandon Lake: six reveals at 100 per cent bought, common of 15,733 tickets per gig, common gross of US$889,512.
- Anuel AA: eight reveals at 85 per cent bought, common of 13,794 tickets per gig, common gross of US$1.2 million.
Even Creed, one of the vital ridiculed bands of the final quarter-century, is promoting out reveals with a mean attendance of 11,000 individuals. That’s near one million bucks an evening.
To be clear, none of what I’m saying is the screed of an outdated man pining for the outdated days. I’m merely stating the distinction between how the music world was once and what it’s grow to be.
Whereas the most important labels nonetheless haven’t discovered the best way to take care of this new world, indie labels have extra of an opportunity. Songs and artists bubble up on-line via streamers and social media and find yourself discovering their viewers, particular person by particular person. Finally, there are sufficient of them to band collectively right into a group for that artist, communities that, whereas giant, are largely invisible to everybody else.
One other paradigm is to create a superfan constituency. In case you can persuade simply 3,000 individuals to pay you $10 a month for all types of unique entry and particular privileges, that’s $360,000 a yr. Not dangerous.
Now, for those who’ll excuse me, I have to take heed to the brand new Jehnny Beth album, You Heartbreaker You. It’s wonderful. Everybody’s listening to it–or at the least must be.
© 2025 World Information, a division of Corus Leisure Inc.